Sunday, December 31, 2006

Don't Put Me in That Box

While looking for some other stuff, I came across this from Angela Bonavoglia. My comments are in red.
Imagine this conversation at the altar rail: (When is the last time she or anyone saw an altar rail, much less recieved the Eucharist at one)Are you now or have you ever been a member of Call to Action? If the answer is yes, and you live in the diocese of Lincoln, Nebraska, there will be no Communion for you. Nor will you be able to participate in a Catholic baptism or even have a Catholic burial. (Ummm, they can participate. They just can't be a godparent. Participation has many forms. Moreover, repudiating their association with the organization and confessing their sins when they are in danger of death lifts the excommunication)

As a Christmas gift to Lincoln's progressive Church reformers, Cardinal Giovanni Battista Re, head of the Vatican Congregation of Bishops, heartily approved the Inquisitional action of Bishop Fabian Bruskewitz, who excommunicated every single local member of the country's largest and most progressive church reform group, Call to Action. (A big cheer from this section.)

Bruskewitz originally excommunicated local CTA members in 1996 (no one said the Vatican works fast), when the Lincoln CTA chapter was formed. Ironically, CTA was founded in 1976 by the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops to increase lay participation in church affairs. (See what happens when people forget that the Church belongs to God.)
Independent of the church today, CTA supports a broad range of issues, many favored by the majority of U.S. Catholics, like ending clerical celibacy, ordaining women, greater lay power in church affairs, and lifting the illogical and indefensible ban on birth control. (Illogical? No, there is plenty of logic behind it. And it is definately defendable. WE SHOULDN'T HAVE TO CONTROL EVERYTHING!)

Bruskewitz declared membership in CTA (as well as in such other organizations as Planned Parenthood and Catholics for a Free Choice) as "always perilous to...and totally incompatible with the Catholic faith." (Another cheer!) He gave members one week to renounce their membership or be "automatically excommunicated." Lincoln CTA appealed that decision. In his letter of response, Cardinal Re confirmed that membership in or support of CTA was "irreconcilable with a coherent living of the Catholic faith," and declared that Bruskewitz's decision to issue a blanket excommunication was "properly taken."

It's an astonishing development. First, this is a mass excommunication. It flies in the face of a tradition of such actions being seen as drastic and taken only on an individual level, though the Church's record in that regard (excommunicating people who later are made saints) is pretty abyssal. (Really? I will admit that some saints had been excommunicated at one point, but the number is very low. Also, this type of excommunication is not unheard of.)

Second, it demonizes some of the world's most articulate, progressive Catholic spiritual leaders who are involved with Call to Action. They include people like Sister Jeannine Gramick, who built a pioneering ministry to gays and lesbians despite Vatican orders to silence her and ban her work; Bishop Thomas Gumbleton, an outspoken advocate for clergy sex abuse survivors; and Sister Joan Chittister, a giant among Church reformers, who the Vatican failed to silence on the subject of women's ordination when her entire Benedictine order rose up in her defense. (Talk about great Catholics. @@)

This excommunication order also attests to the fact that Bruskewitz is a unchecked despot, clerically speaking. In fact, Bruskewitz is the only diocesan bishop who has self-righteously repudiated the legitimacy of the U.S. Bishops' Charter on the Protection of Children and Young People by steadfastly refusing to allow an audit of clergy sex abuse of children in his diocese. In addition, Bruskewitz is the only bishop in the U.S. that forbids altar girls.

Which brings me to my last point. Banishing from the church family the whole membership of organizations like Call to Action in fact banishes the strongest advocates for change in the Church: women. As I illustrate in my book Good Catholic Girls: How Women Are Leading the Fight to Change the Church, many progressive Catholic organizations were founded by women, are led by women, and have large female constituencies. (Don't dare lump me into that group. There are more faithful female Catholics than there are women is groups like CTA. There are also many conservative and moderate Catholic groups lead by women. Not all women are heirarchy haters and rule breakers. We do not all feel oppressed by the Church, In fact, a large number of us love the Church deeply and do not feel oppressed at all.)

At this year's national CTA conference, on the occasion of the organization's 30th anniversary, Sister Joan Chittister was the keynote speaker. Taking God's instructions to Abraham, Moses, Joshua, Ezechiel, and the women and the people of Jerusalem to "rise up," she demands the same of her audience. "Speak up, speak out, speak on," she urges, for peace, justice, the poor, ecumenism, and women's rights--in the church and in the world.

Clearly, her charge to Catholic reformers to press on promises to become increasingly difficult and dangerous in the months ahead. But that's not dissuading CTA Lincoln; they've appealed their excommunication again, to the Vatican's highest court.

Excuse me while I vomit!

Update: The link is fixed.


Lynne said...

The link to her article doesn't seem to work...

DominiSumus said...

Thanks, I just fixed it.